Author |
Topic |
chickenbone
Panama
398 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 10:01:51
|
I agree with you Eric. First of all, a lot of people dislike talk of the unconscious. It is difficult to even describe the unconscious because many people have different concepts of it. Some think of it as just any material that is not immediately available to the conscious mind. They think of it kind of like a quantum computer complete with deep storage. Others think of it as more of an intelligent entity in a more organic sense. However you want to think of it, I find that people who resist the notion of it are basically "control freaks". They cannot deal with the idea that there maybe parts of their own mind that they do not have immediate control over. I think these people can be extremely resistant to any type of psychological therapy.
I think that depth psychology is not so much about routing around in the murky past and digging up repressed material as it is about discovering very primitive belief systems that may be operating under the level of conscious awareness. This is what I think of as "emotional truths". These primitive belief systems may be greatly at odds with the conscious mind and can greatly interfere with one's life in the present. Often, for healing to happen, these need to be integrated with the conscious mind. The conscious mind needs to at least be aware of them. Our very early life experiences often dictate how this will go. This is hard for me to describe but maybe I can provide an example from my own past.
Because I suffered some physical and emotional abuse as a child and my emotional needs were not met, I grew up regarding the world as a dangerous place. Because of my fear and small size, I became the perfect object for other older children to mercilessly terrorize and pick on. I did not think well of human nature in general. Many early life experiences fed and enhanced this growing belief system under the surface. But I managed to cope with it by gradually repressing it. When I became an adult, my conscious mind wanted to be loved and accepted by others and people were really nice to me. It was a very different world from the world in which I grew up. But that early belief system was still there repressed under the surface. And it caused problems in my life. I would often over react emotionally to certain triggers and not know why. I know this sometimes puzzled and concerned people in my life who loved me like my husband, husband's family and my friends, and even some members of my own family.
Unfortunately, this repressed belief system was reinforced because of several experiences that happened when I was a young adult in my 20's. When I was 22, I was the victim of an attempted rape. I had moved out of the suburbs where I lived with my parents to an apartment in a not so good area of the city near the university I attended. Because I was not on good terms with my parents, I was on my own financially and so was attending school full time and working in a restaurant full time as a waitress. One night I got out of work about 12:30 and was walking to the bus stop. I could not afford a car. While I was walking, a car quickly pulled over to the curb, a guy got out and dragged me into a car. He held me down in the back seat by my wrists and when I realized what he intended, I tried to reason with him. I couldn't talk him out of it. He told me he would let me go unharmed if I just cooperated. At that point, I could feel in my mind the switch happening. The "other" hidden entity had taken over. It did not believe him, had no intention of being raped, and was totally focused on getting away even if it meant hurting him badly. And that is exactly what it did. He was no match for it. (from what I remember, he did not have a weapon)I pretended to be cooperating, bit him hard and gave him an unbelievably hard kick in the groin. As I leaped out of the car to get away, I could hear him vomiting and doubling up with pain in the back seat. I came away with only a black eye (he had punched me during the dispute when I tried to talk him out of it). He needed medical attention, not me. Anyway, as you can imagine, this primitive belief system became even stronger.
Unfortunately, it was strongly reinforced 2 other times while I was still in my 20's. I was robbed at gunpoint while working in the restaurant. Again, I felt this entity take over. I felt this cold, calculating calm come over me again while a masked man pointed a gun at me. I calmly gave him all the money in the register, being very careful to do nothing to "set him off" because customers were also in danger (he robbed all the customers also) and then he quickly left. The police did catch him and I identified him in a lineup. Then again, one night (I was 27 at the time), I was walking from my house to my car to go to work. On the sidewalk approaching me were 2 guys. My conscious mind was not concerned and resolved to just pass them on the sidewalk. However, as they approached within the length of one house, alarm bells started going off in my head. It was really deafening, I could not ignore it. So I walked out into the street to pass by them. As I did this, one of them came out into the middle of the street after me, but was not able to grab me because I was prepared for it. I ran for my car and got in and locked the door. I was afraid to go back to the house to call the police, so I drove to work and called the police from there. It turned out that these 2 guys were committing a mini crime spree in the neighborhood that was normally fairly quiet. They had raped one young woman in an alley and beaten her badly, robbed an elderly lady, knocking her down so that she broke her hip and did some other things I don't remember. I was apparently the only one who had escaped them. Anyway, I spent most of the night in the police station looking at mug shots. the police drove me home that night, took me to work the next night and again drove me home. To my knowledge, they were never caught because if they had been, I would have called to court as a witness.
This just goes to show you how your unconscious mind can operate. I think all these experiences have contributed to my TMS. I never talk to anyone about this stuff, but I guess I am better able to come to grips with it now. You can probably imagine how I am feeling while regurgitating all of this right now, but I am OK. Not to long after that my mother passed away and I moved out of the city and joined up with my father in the suburbs of another city. |
|
|
kalo
USA
142 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 10:15:13
|
quote:
quote: In my opinion Kalo, your nervous system is very sensitve. And I think you need to build resistance in it (which to be honest is a very hard process, but doable if you keep practicing). Obviously you are angered by your dad, but try to put a link with your symptoms after you dad says something you dont like etc, Try to be conscious of these things and next time he does it try not to let it simulate your nerves, say your affirmations and desensitize yourself. You will want to react like you did, bc it is easier, but dont go with it and act the opposite once your aware. Affirmations really do help, but only over time after consistant use. Good Luck
ACE, GREAT ADVICE!!!!! So, you see is it really my Subconcious??? OR is it my current stressors???
I really appreciate BOTH sides of the subconcious and current stressors!!!
I still love your KEYS, ACE, I am TRYING like heck to not stress out...REPROGRAMMING is TOUGH, but, I am determined...
Thanks,
Kalo
|
|
|
kalo
USA
142 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 10:17:14
|
Chickenbone,
Wow, reading the difficulties you had in life makes me feel like my problems are nothing...
The way you describe yourself, wanting to be loved, and for people to like you sounds just like me...
Can, I ask, did you unlock your unconious to make the TMS go away?
I agree, I am programmed with a set of belief systems as well....We learned this as we are young...
Kalo |
|
|
eric watson
USA
601 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 10:27:46
|
quote: Originally posted by chickenbone
I agree with you Eric. First of all, a lot of people dislike talk of the unconscious. It is difficult to even describe the unconscious because many people have different concepts of it. Some think of it as just any material that is not immediately available to the conscious mind. They think of it kind of like a quantum computer complete with deep storage. Others think of it as more of an intelligent entity in a more organic sense. However you want to think of it, I find that people who resist the notion of it are basically "control freaks". They cannot deal with the idea that there maybe parts of their own mind that they do not have immediate control over. I think these people can be extremely resistant to any type of psychological therapy.
I think that depth psychology is not so much about routing around in the murky past and digging up repressed material as it is about discovering very primitive belief systems that may be operating under the level of conscious awareness. This is what I think of as "emotional truths". These primitive belief systems may be greatly at odds with the conscious mind and can greatly interfere with one's life in the present. Often, for healing to happen, these need to be integrated with the conscious mind. The conscious mind needs to at least be aware of them. Our very early life experiences often dictate how this will go. This is hard for me to describe but maybe I can provide an example from my own past.
Because I suffered some physical and emotional abuse as a child and my emotional needs were not met, I grew up regarding the world as a dangerous place. Because of my fear and small size, I became the perfect object for other older children to mercilessly terrorize and pick on. I did not think well of human nature in general. Many early life experiences fed and enhanced this growing belief system under the surface. But I managed to cope with it by gradually repressing it. When I became an adult, my conscious mind wanted to be loved and accepted by others and people were really nice to me. It was a very different world from the world in which I grew up. But that early belief system was still there repressed under the surface. And it caused problems in my life. I would often over react emotionally to certain triggers and not know why. I know this sometimes puzzled and concerned people in my life who loved me like my husband, husband's family and my friends, and even some members of my own family.
Unfortunately, this repressed belief system was reinforced because of several experiences that happened when I was a young adult in my 20's. When I was 22, I was the victim of an attempted rape. I had moved out of the suburbs where I lived with my parents to an apartment in a not so good area of the city near the university I attended. Because I was not on good terms with my parents, I was on my own financially and so was attending school full time and working in a restaurant full time as a waitress. One night I got out of work about 12:30 and was walking to the bus stop. I could not afford a car. While I was walking, a car quickly pulled over to the curb, a guy got out and dragged me into a car. He held me down in the back seat by my wrists and when I realized what he intended, I tried to reason with him. I couldn't talk him out of it. He told me he would let me go unharmed if I just cooperated. At that point, I could feel in my mind the switch happening. The "other" hidden entity had taken over. It did not believe him, had no intention of being raped, and was totally focused on getting away even if it meant hurting him badly. And that is exactly what it did. He was no match for it. (from what I remember, he did not have a weapon)I pretended to be cooperating, bit him hard and gave him an unbelievably hard kick in the groin. As I leaped out of the car to get away, I could hear him vomiting and doubling up with pain in the back seat. I came away with only a black eye (he had punched me during the dispute when I tried to talk him out of it). He needed medical attention, not me. Anyway, as you can imagine, this primitive belief system became even stronger.
Unfortunately, it was strongly reinforced 2 other times while I was still in my 20's. I was robbed at gunpoint while working in the restaurant. Again, I felt this entity take over. I felt this cold, calculating calm come over me again while a masked man pointed a gun at me. I calmly gave him all the money in the register, being very careful to do nothing to "set him off" because customers were also in danger (he robbed all the customers also) and then he quickly left. The police did catch him and I identified him in a lineup. Then again, one night (I was 27 at the time), I was walking from my house to my car to go to work. On the sidewalk approaching me were 2 guys. My conscious mind was not concerned and resolved to just pass them on the sidewalk. However, as they approached within the length of one house, alarm bells started going off in my head. It was really deafening, I could not ignore it. So I walked out into the street to pass by them. As I did this, one of them came out into the middle of the street after me, but was not able to grab me because I was prepared for it. I ran for my car and got in and locked the door. I was afraid to go back to the house to call the police, so I drove to work and called the police from there. It turned out that these 2 guys were committing a mini crime spree in the neighborhood that was normally fairly quiet. They had raped one young woman in an alley and beaten her badly, robbed an elderly lady, knocking her down so that she broke her hip and did some other things I don't remember. I was apparently the only one who had escaped them. Anyway, I spent most of the night in the police station looking at mug shots. the police drove me home that night, took me to work the next night and again drove me home. To my knowledge, they were never caught because if they had been, I would have called to court as a witness.
This just goes to show you how your unconscious mind can operate. I think all these experiences have contributed to my TMS. I never talk to anyone about this stuff, but I guess I am better able to come to grips with it now. You can probably imagine how I am feeling while regurgitating all of this right now, but I am OK. Not to long after that my mother passed away and I moved out of the city and joined up with my father in the suburbs of another city.
of course you are a warrior chicken bone we all have negatives that turn out to help us later and were like well, ok yours is ok too- and im glad you got to get that out here on the forum that's how I journaled repressions as I grew you have a good hold on all of this- the reasons for beliefs and your story is powerful- send me an e mail if you'd like to talk - sounds like your doing well
|
|
|
eric watson
USA
601 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 10:31:08
|
quote: Originally posted by kalo
Chickenbone,
Wow, reading the difficulties you had in life makes me feel like my problems are nothing...
The way you describe yourself, wanting to be loved, and for people to like you sounds just like me...
Can, I ask, did you unlock your unconious to make the TMS go away?
I agree, I am programmed with a set of belief systems as well....We learned this as we are young...
Kalo
you got it kalo, thanks chickenbone but remember to do aces tensive training too its a must -less you already have control of your thoughts |
|
|
chickenbone
Panama
398 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 10:36:40
|
I just want to say how much I value Ace's Keys and I still use them on a daily basis. They really help me to cope and they were extremely instrumental in the start of my recovery from TMS.
Hi Kalo, I hope people are getting the "point" of my relating these experiences. It is to show how this unconscious belief system can be operating under the surface. It can become active under appropriate or inappropriate circumstances. Obviously, it saved me from becoming a victim of crime, but it also causes problems in my life when it mistakes benign life experiences for danger. I think perhaps my TMS stems from my inability to completely integrate this primitive belief system with my fully conscious mind. I may have also decided on some derogatory beliefs about myself because of these experiences along the lines of "these things would not have happened to me if I was a better person" or "people would not like me if I shared some of this stuff". Even though I have mostly "unlocked" it, it has not been integrated into one coherent belief system. Is the world really dangerous or is it safe? I just don't know. I have not been able to come to a integrated, stable belief about such existential topics. |
|
|
eric watson
USA
601 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 10:42:44
|
chicken bone write me and lets talk you don't need hold the hurt in order to know the lesson but the memory can be switched as in it has no negative charge if you got a memory you can learn to discharge it but still keep the benefits from it ya know.
kalo- e mail me so we can talk about how to rid those repressions
im here to help guys.
The reason I like e mails is its more 1 on 1
if you know consciously what's bothering you then we can make the negative charge of less to no effect |
Edited by - eric watson on 03/27/2013 10:48:40 |
|
|
chickenbone
Panama
398 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 10:46:58
|
Thanks, Eric, you are a darling. I also want to thank Ace and Dr. Alexander as well as all the people here who have helped me.
|
|
|
eric watson
USA
601 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 10:50:49
|
Thank you chickenbone- I mean my warrior |
|
|
Ace1
USA
1040 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 11:22:22
|
Hi Alix, I have a theory of why you experienced what you did. I also on occasion if I thought of that angry child it would lessen my symptoms. I think the way it works is that it somehow takes your mind away from the intense strain thought that is habitual (lets say being in a rush for example). to something else that can capture your attention enough. Since the thought of this angry child is not yet a habit, it doesn't stay with you or reinforce the tension associated with the original strained habit. So in a way it breaks you train of though and doesn't reinforce it bc it is a different pattern of thinking. In the long run though I don't think it's as good as working on it from the other end. |
|
|
eric watson
USA
601 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 12:21:36
|
that's it ace when the thought is broken by experiencing a good thought at the peak of the bad thought to distinguish the bad thought when you try to think of it again then the charge or bad feelings or negative emotions to that thought is gone
if theres resistance it won't work
look at nlp decision destroyer or the nlp white out techniques
but this is to be studied after learning submodalities work
Guys it like this- I healed first with tms healing therapy but I had these memories that I couldn't let go or even wanted to look at again so I learnt how to discharge negative memories and you have to be willing ya know
|
Edited by - eric watson on 03/27/2013 12:24:49 |
|
|
alix
USA
434 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 12:40:10
|
Thanks Ace. Food for thoughts. But do you understand why my brain chose to give me "knee pain" for 30 minutes instead of my usual symptoms. That was just so random and hard to take seriously. Almost the work of a "child" trying to prank me. Don't get me wrong, the behavioral part was huge in my recovery. I am much calmer, more attentive to others, and don't try to rush or get over things as quickly as possible.
|
|
|
Ace1
USA
1040 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 13:54:01
|
Dear alix, please refer back to my analogy of the squeeze (stress) ball that when you squeeze it, it herniates out from the area od least resistance. Imagine if the force on the ball is very strong, well, it is likely the herniation will remain fixed where it is, but as you lessen the pressure, it is more apt to herniate anywhere where the resistance is less. As you release the pressure completely, then the ball does not deform at all. I think this is how it works in TMS. Let me know if you dont understand what I have tried to explain. |
|
|
alix
USA
434 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 14:09:46
|
Yes Ace that makes sense. Thanks. In fact now that I think about it I had a knee injury when I was younger and the neural pathway just got reactivated. |
|
|
RikR
USA
94 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 15:00:51
|
Strain is a cognitive driven behavior. If you want to lessen the internal stress you have to look beyond strain to see what is the root cause/belief.
This is good example why doing regressive inquiry (digging for old emotions does not work) the digging and hoping to find the “big one” is a major distraction from looking right now,today at what personality traits and beliefs you hold that cause the pain and suffering.
Trying to lessen strain without having a core understanding of the real cause is just more will power driven strain. At some point we decided (those who strain) it helped them survive or reach a desired goal.
My educational path was much the same as Ace’s – it is darn hard to survive the rigors and not strain. In fact I believe the path of medicine is one that attracts people who push and if you don’t you may not make it! I was so burnt out after graduation I lied about my education and went to work in a warehouse for 6 months to recuperate.
The epiphany of how and why we are the way we are, right now...TODAY is the Holy Grail. |
|
|
alix
USA
434 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 15:54:29
|
So RikR, what do you think about the reconsolidation theory from Bruce Ecker et al? |
|
|
Dr James Alexander
Australia
127 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 16:32:03
|
Chickenbone- you have perfectly articulated the role of the unconscious in all this, as well as personal history of traumas etc. There are ways of reconciling these realities with a focus on now, cognitive schemas etc. You are showing how this is done in a lived-in experience way; and therapists/authors like Ecker, Ticic & Hulley (Unlocking the Emotional Brian) are showing the role of this stuff in helping people to get better. Thanks for your contributions- they are very illuminating for a lot of people.
James |
|
|
RikR
USA
94 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 16:32:03
|
This is the basis of Ecker’s theory: Through reconsolidation, the unwanted neural circuits are unwired and cannot relapse.
First lets talk about theories in psychology – they are a dime a thousand. We in the industry want so bad to have a theory than many spend their whole lives trying to come up with one. If you are in academia you better have one if you want to keep working. Publish or perish!!
Then you explore the premise and the supporting evidence. I have seen several citations where he twists other researchers conclusions. And the whole premise of unwiring neural circuits is not found in any reputable neuroscience.
Let me give you a simple example: I used to race sports cars in my 20’s – I shifted a 6 speed many thousand times. I have not driven a stick shift in over 40 years. I took a Mini Cooper in trade for a boat last week and without hesitation I ran through the gears and double clutched just like I was back on the track. Spent a few days on the worst mountain roads I could find with great joy.
Now if you could extinct a memory circuit I would think 40 years of driving an automatic would do it. Emotional memories are not as concrete as process memories but once laid down into memory something a small as smell or a sound can bring them back from storage. If you were ever attacked by a black dog I can guarantee you that that fear of black dogs emotion can be brought back even 90 years later with the right triggers.
People with far more education and experience in neuroscience than I have looked at his theory and found it “circumstantial” at best. |
|
|
eric watson
USA
601 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 16:45:39
|
Don't knock what you haven't tried
just cause you don't believe it doesn't make it less effective
I just used it moments ago on a lady that had pain to a 10
then when we finished it was a three- she's bed- ridden
so I left the three there- shes knows now so she will find her way and finish.
no reconsolidation is not a dime a dozen
I wish it were-
we need know processes before we say that don't work
you know a lot of stuff Rik, but tell me when have you tried reconsolidation
That is the only factor that you don't get
well that and sarnos theory
and the 40 year automatic story would be the repression that would be flipped if it were allowed
let me give you one rik- 40 yrs ago that car was good to go huh
today with no up keep- it would be rust
the reconsolidation would take away the rust
then you got to go and buy the paint
paint the car real pretty,
and this old car will be running again
now rik explain this to me and if you come close- well
|
Edited by - eric watson on 03/27/2013 17:01:26 |
|
|
pspa123
672 Posts |
Posted - 03/27/2013 : 17:31:46
|
So Rik you didn't answer me before, are the practitioners who say they have had success with depth psychology methods such as Arlene Feinblatt (Dr. Sarno's therapist), our own James Alexander, Howard Schubiner, etc. etc., and their patients, just lying or wrong? It's fine to give your opinion but you make statements like "digging for repressed emotions does not work" as though you have some monopoly on truth. By the way, remind us please of your background if you would, since you seem to have a lot of medical education, thanks. |
|
|
Topic |
|
|
|